Working Notes of a Practising Neo-Generalist (#15) — To be everywhere is to be nowhere
“If anyone can refute me — show me I’m making a mistake or looking at things from the wrong perspective — I’ll gladly change. It’s the truth I’m after, and the truth never harmed anyone. What harms us is to persist in self-deceit and ignorance.” — Marcus Aurelius in Meditations, Book 6:21 (Gregory Hays, The Modern Library, New York)
To be everywhere is to be nowhere
Since I started using Twitter in 2012, I have mostly shared other people’s tweets, and, by doing so, created a library with more than 10,000 talks, blog posts, articles, thoughts and ideas on subjects ranging from innovation and leadership to philosophy and architecture. This collection may seem random but, to me, these varied subjects are all connected, one way or the other. In the words of the French philosopher Michel de Montaigne, “I have gathered a posy of other men’s flowers, and nothing but the thread that binds them is mine own.”
I make these connections in notebooks but, above all, in my head, and they become explicit through my work as executive mentor and transformation architect. This is where and how my thinking as ‘comprehensivist’ pays out. Until I started following Harold Jarche’s online course in Personal Knowledge Mastery (PKM), that is. Harold made me realise the importance of working out (even) loud(er).
Since 2016, I share some of my connections in ‘Random finds’ — my weekly curation of tweets. With an average read time of fifteen minutes, slowly creeping up to twenty, I don’t expect to attract a large audience. But I don’t mind. Writing these Random finds has actually made me a better reader, which, in turn, allows me to make more meaningful connections between concepts and ideas, and also between and with people.
In 2017, I also wrote the final issue in a series of columns for Intrapreneurship World (rebranded as Innov8rs), a transcript of Secrets of Silicon Valley, a BBC documentary series by tech writer Jamie Bartlett, and eleven ‘Working Notes of a Practicing Neo-Generalist.’
These Working Notes are my stories, and I owe much of it to Richard Martin and Kenneth Mikkelsen, the authors of The Neo-Generalist. My interview for their book, and the many conversations I have had with Kenneth since, have made me more aware of my ‘onlyness’ — a term coined by Nilofer Merchant, with which she means, the “thing that only you have, coming from that spot in the world in which you stand, a function of your history and experience, visions and hopes. It is everything that you have coming from your past, that only you can see.”
Having said this, I don’t see myself as a writer. Like Montaigne, and that is where the comparison stops, I am a ‘réfléchisseur’ — someone who reflects, who ponders.
Lately, I have been asking myself the question, how long will I be able to keep this up? I don’t have an answer yet, although I think it’s time to find a new and more accessible format for my ‘threads.’ Besides, I want to write more about the books I read. After all, the hundred or so institutions, journals and people I follow on Twitter aren’t my only source of information. Far from it. But I also want to spend my time wisely. Or, as Seneca wrote in one of his Moral Letters to Lucilius (Letter 2, On discursiveness in reading), “Be careful, however, that there is no element of discursiveness and desultoriness about this reading you refer to, this reading of many different authors and books of every description. You should be extending your stay among writers whose genius is unquestionable, deriving constant nourishment from them if you wish to gain anything from your reading that will find a lasting place in your mind. To be everywhere is to be nowhere.”
So, plenty to ponder on during the coming weeks. But for now, here’s the list of my writings from 2017.
Random finds
An almost weekly curation of my tweets and, as such, a reflection of my curiosity and the connections I make.
- Random finds (2017, week 52) — On the rise of global cities and those left behind, the case for the humanities, and boredom
- Random finds (2017, week 51) — On the danger of elite projection, Facebook’s algorithms, and leadership and purpose beyond ‘feel-good lines’
- Random finds (2017, week 50) — On powerful habits, ceremonies of innocence, and what’s missing from machines
- Random finds (2017, week 49) — On Hippy Taylorism, the quitting economy, and why time management is ruining our lives
- Random finds (2017, week 48) — On the case against civilization, how our buildings deeply affect us, and business bullshit
- Random finds (2017, week 47) — On our cult of “genius,” the long history of the gig economy, and the remorseless logic of specialisation
- Random finds (2017, week 46) — On liminal leadership, the paradox of growth, and the balance of humility and hubris
- Random finds (2017, week 45) — On the need for humanity-centered design, a philosophy of digital minimalism, and the silence in between
- Random finds (2017, week 44) — On curing affluenza, our sickly-sweet obsession with comfort, and the science of the wandering mind
- Random finds (2017, week 43) — On how AI might take over the world, Big Data meets Big Brother, and the new urban crisis
- Random finds (2017, week 42) — On Silicon Valley (“as the wrecking ball that it is”), ‘urbanism as a service,’ and why the future looks like the past
- Random finds (2017, week 41) — On AI (and mistaken predictions), curiosity, and the lost art of invention
- Random finds (2017, week 35–36) — A visual “posy of other men’s flowers”
- Random finds (2017, week 34) — On the ‘robots are taking over’ rhetoric, the new urban crisis, and Silicon Valley’s new oil
- Random finds (2017, week 33) — On Secrets of Silicon Valley (part 2), Eliminating the Human, and cognitive diversity
- Random finds (2017, week 32) — On Secrets of Silicon Valley (part 1), Google and diversity, and a case for scientism
- Random finds (2017, week 31) — On the New Optimists’ ideological argument, our desire to know, and the death of reading
- Random finds (2017, week 30) — On the quitting economy, the virtues of boredom, and solitude
- Random finds (2017, week 29) — On the rise and fall of globalisation, Ayn Rand’s extreme libertarianism, and ‘guff-talkers’
- Random finds (2017, week 27–28) — On what we get wrong about technology, a pluralist, and the pop-up employer
- Random finds (2017, week 26) — On the case against thought leaders, the crisis of expertise, and “a building roughly the shape of a navel”
- Random finds (2017, week 24–25) — On the rise and fall of Uber’s Travis Kalanick, ethical innovation, and why creators are not mere experts
- Random finds (2017, week 23) — On the crisis of expertise, the Internet of Things (who is it good for?), and serendipitous design
- Random finds (2017, week 22) — On science and the importance of ‘fooling around,’ Adorno and the remains of the Frankfurt School, and the Homo Prospectus
- Random finds (2017, week 21) — On excellence, practice, and improvisation (and jazz)
- Random finds (2017, week 20) — On the decline of innovation (or not), accelerationism, and the useless class of the post-work world
- Random finds (2017, week 19) — On the value of our built environment, the virtues of boredom, and the curse of the consultants
- Random finds (2017, week 18) — On the myth of flow, why design thinking needs to think bigger, and the knowledge illusion
- Random finds (2017, week 17) — On alien knowledge, what makes a genius, and a letter to humanity
- Random finds (2017, week 16) — On AI’s mysterious mind, raising good robots, and how Western civilisation could collapse
- Random finds (2017, week 15) — On creativity and true genius, why expertise matters, and the cult of the entrepreneur
- Random finds (2017, week 14) — On the merits of hierarchy, the revival of artisanship, and addictive noise
- Random finds (2017, week 13) — On Silicon Valley’s quest for immortality, true character, and the need for followers
- Random finds (2017, week 12) — On consumerism, long shots and punctuated equilibrium, and why Silicon Valley needs to get schooled
- Random finds (2017, week 11) — On inequality as a feature (not a bug), why facts alone won’t change your mind, and calling bullshit
- Random finds (2017, week 10) — On the cult of the ‘Great White Innovator,’ AI’s PR problem, and the revenge of analog
- Random finds (2017, week 9) — On grassroots algorithms, short-lived Utopian communities, and shared creativity
- Random finds (2017, week 8) — On Zuckerberg’s well-intended manifesto, a technologized world, and Dataism
- Random finds (2017, week 7) — On cyborgs and a world without consciousness, faux futurists, and the age of rudeness
- Random finds (2017, week 6) — On saving humanity’s 0.014035087719298244 percent, the need for new economic thinking, and collage
- Random finds (2017, week 5) — On the new, multipolar global economy, the throughput of learning, and why we should leave Mars alone
- Random finds (2017, week 4) — On the future of AI, Trump’s assault on the Enlightenment, and More ‘vs.’ Malthus
- Random finds (2017, week 3) — On Trump’s manufacturing jobs, Obama’s farewell, and Moontopia
- Random finds (2017, week 2) — On AI’s prompters, the future of work, and the need for pattern recognition
- Random finds (2017, week 1) — On the first world cyberwar, disappearing jobs, and Ways of Seeing
Working Notes of a Practising Neo-Generalist
An assembly of personal thoughts and reflections.
- #14 — On bubbles and the need for cognitive diversity
- #13 — On the loss of ‘humanness’
- #12 — On being a ‘Time Lord’
- #11 — On ‘plonk work’
- #10 — On good places, yet nowhere to be found
- #09 — On aiming higher and higher
- #08 — On foresight and the role of doubt
- #07 — On foresight and king Príamos’ daughter
- #06 — On Confucius and our need for ‘ren’
- #05 — On false façades and smoke screens
- #04 — On Personal Knowledge Mastery (or 2016: A year in writing)
Previous issues (2016)
- #03 — On wandering minds (and feet)
- #02 — On return on investment (yours and mine)
- #01 — On being neither in nor out
Field Notes on Innovation and Entrepreneurship
Issue #11 was my final column in a series written for Intrapreneurship World (rebranded in 2017 as Innov8rs), posted between September 19th, 2016, and January 10th, 2017.
- Issue #11 — On the failing religion of business
Previous issues (2016)
- Issue #10 — On the lack of principles
- Issue #09 — On rebels with a cause
- Issue #08 — On small mice, giants and confusion
- Issue #07 — On innovation snobbery
- Issue #06 — On asking beautiful questions
- Issue #05 — On design thinking as a panacea
- Issue #04 — On the need for deeper innovation
- Issue #03 — On solving non-existing problems
- Issue #02 — On disruption
- Issue #01 — On innovation labs
Secrets of Silicon Valley
In August 2017, the BBC broadcasted a two-part series by tech writer Jamie Bartlett, The Secrets of Silicon Valley, in which he tried to uncover the dark reality behind Silicon Valley’s glittering promise to build a better world.
And finally…
- 2,413 tweets
“Humanities? Law? Tourism? Zoology? Politics? History? Art? Maths? Philosophy? Music? Languages? Classics? Engineering? Architecture? Economics? Medicine? Psychology? Daniel said.
All of the above, Elisabeth said.
That’s why you need to go to collage, Daniel said.”
— Ali Smith in Autumn